|
|
|
-
 
-
Shadows Over My Berlin:
-
One Woman's Story of World War II
BY HEIDI SCRIBA VANCE
With Janet Barton Speer, Ph.D.
ISBN: 0-913337-30-7; Hardcover; 200 pages;
Library of Congress Catalog #: 96-41917;
Retail $25.00
Ordinary German lives during
the holocaust, by someone
who was an ordinary German
with a front row seat
“With her candor about German response to the
Nazis (in Shadows Over My Berlin), Vance invites
confrontation with the very current question posed
by Daniel Goldhagen in his 1996 book, Hitler’s
Willing Executioners: Ordinary Germans and
the Holocaust. Did the Nazis benefit from the
collaboration of ordinary German citizens in killing
Jews?
“Vance answers indirectly: “It was impossible
for any of us to know the truth. My talking about
(the “Jewish Problem”) could be dangerous to me
and my family. And I could not change government
policy by myself. Fear is a great immobilizer.”
“That answer itself demonstrates that at best,
Vance and her family were an exception to
the rule,
and at the least, demonstrated what Goldhagen
proposes, that anti-Semitism was so imbued in society
that the removal of Jews from a community was
not perceived as a threat to the entire community.
Protest would be a threat.
“She presents a vivid example of just such a removal,
as Nazis come, beat and take away a Jewish
couple and an old woman, then return to strip
the apartment of all its belongings.
“‘Look at this stuff,’ one laughed. ‘Good stuff!
Rich! Expensive! We need this in our homes.’” When
Vance leaned over the banister to get a better
look, Papa was close behind her. “‘Watch it!’ he
whispered. ‘If they see you, they may not like
it.’”
“The permission for the Nazis’ behavior, an acceptance
that overwhelms resistance, is palpable in
moments such as these and others in the book.
Vance notes, “Who was ashamed? Who was not?
I didn’t know. Germans kept their opinions, their
thoughts, even their fears to themselves.”
“Then she immediately observes that the blue-collar
masses “…seemed to be in agreement with him (Hitler).”
She presents a weak defense when she notes that
they didn’t disapprove—“Not outwardly, anyway.”
Never was the word “anyway” so revealing.”
This is “…a poignant tale of a powerful human
being, providing us pictures of little-known history,
and a clear-cut presentation of a hotly debated
question of ethical behavior:
two good reasons to read
this book.”
—Robert Moyer
Winston-Salem
Journal
Book Review, May
7, 1997
If the Nazis did benefit from the collaboration
and complicity of ordinary Germans in killing Jews, Heidi
Scriba Vance would know. She was in her late teens
and early twenties during World War II. She resided
in Berlin and was beginning a career as a ballerina
as the war unfolded on her doorstep. Now
80-years-old, she recounts her experiences, as
well as those of her parents, doctor, aunts and many
friends. In Shadows Over My Berlin, Scriba
reveals the forgotten history of ordinary Germans
prior to and during World War II.
Shadows Over My Berlin:
One Woman's Story of World
War II
Retail $25 plus shipping and handling
Order Shadows Over My Berlin
one of two ways!
To order by credit card, click...
To order by mail and pay by check or money order,
mail your payment to:
Southfarm Press, Publisher
P.O. Box 1296
Middletown, CT 06457
Be sure to provide your mailing address
and phone number with your check.
|